Canada · Canadian Dollar

How to Sell Gold in Canada: Prices, Taxes, Dealers

A display of gold and silver rings in a jewellery store — how to sell gold in Canada for the best price

Selling gold in Canada is usually simpler than buying it — but offers can vary by hundreds of dollars between buyers, and the gap is rarely luck. Dealers pay the value of the metal minus their margin, which depends on what you are selling, how it is tested, and how much competition you create. Understand those three things before you walk into a shop and you will keep most of the difference.

This guide explains dealer pricing, assay and ID checks, capital gains basics, and how to compare quotes fairly. Worked examples use round illustrative figures, not live prices — check the gold price today in Canada before you sell, because spot moves through the day.

How dealers price your gold: spot minus margin

Every serious buyer starts from the same number: the live spot price in Canadian dollars per troy ounce, converted to a per-gram value for your karat. From that melt value the dealer deducts a margin covering refining or resale costs, price risk while the metal sits in inventory, and profit. You receive the melt value minus that margin — never the full spot price.

The margin depends mostly on the form of your gold: sealed bars and standard coins resell easily, so dealers deduct the least, while jewellery and scrap must be melted and refined, so the deduction is larger.

What you are sellingTypical dealer deduction from melt valueWhy
Sealed bullion bars and standard coinsAbout 1–3% below spotInstantly resalable
Unsealed bars and coins in good conditionAbout 2–5% below spotTesting costs, slower resale
Gold jewellery, 14K and 18KAbout 5–15% below melt valueRefining; design value not paid
Broken jewellery and dental goldAbout 10–20% below melt valueSorting and refining

Work out your melt value first. For example, if spot is an illustrative CAD $180 per gram for pure 24K gold, a 10-gram 18K bracelet holds 7.5 grams of pure gold (10 × 18/24), so its melt value is 7.5 × $180 = $1,350. A dealer deducting 10% would offer about $1,215; a $900 offer for that bracelet is a margin problem, not the market. Our gold calculator gives you the melt value for any weight and karat, and our sell gold estimator models what a sale might return.

Assay: how a dealer tests your gold

Tax forms with a calculator and pencils — the tax side of selling gold in Canada
Tax forms with a calculator and pencils — the tax side of selling gold in Canada. Photo: Nataliya Vaitkevich / Pexels.

Assay is the dealer's purity test, and it decides what you are paid. Expect one of these methods — and be wary of a buyer who will not explain which one they used.

Hallmark and visual check

The dealer reads the stamp — 999, 750, 585, 18K, 14K — and inspects for wear, repairs and non-gold parts such as clasps, springs and stones, which are weighed or estimated and excluded from the gold weight.

Acid and electronic testing

A small acid scratch test, or a handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) gun, gives a fast, non-destructive purity reading. XRF is the standard at most reputable dealers because it leaves the piece intact.

Fire assay and melting

For scrap lots, the buyer may melt the metal and assay the result — accurate but destructive, so agree the price basis in writing first.

Sealed products with assay certificates, such as Royal Canadian Mint bars, usually skip testing entirely and fetch the best prices; keep the packaging and certificate.

Identification and records: what to bring

Reputable Canadian dealers ask for government-issued photo ID and keep a record of the transaction: item description, weight, purity and price paid. Dealers in precious metals also have obligations under Canada's anti-money-laundering rules administered by FINTRAC, particularly for large cash transactions, and may ask about the source of the gold. Bring photo ID, your original invoice if you still have it, and any assay certificate. A receipt is not legally required, but it speeds the process and supports your tax records.

For inherited gold, bring what documentation you have — a will, estate letter or probate document — and tell the dealer plainly. Most dealers handle estate sales routinely. A buyer who asks for no ID and offers cash with no paperwork is a warning sign, not a convenience.

Capital gains tax basics: what sellers should know

This section is general information, not tax advice — speak to a qualified tax professional before a large sale.

When you sell gold in Canada at a profit, the gain is generally a capital gain. Only half — the 50% inclusion rate — is added to your taxable income, taxed at your marginal rate, not a separate flat rate. Your gain is the sale proceeds minus your adjusted cost base (ACB): what you originally paid plus acquisition costs such as dealer premiums, shipping and insurance. Selling expenses, including dealer commission, reduce your net proceeds.

Two distinctions matter. First, investment-grade bullion of 99.5% purity or higher is generally GST/HST-exempt as a transaction, while jewellery is a taxable consumer good — but GST/HST treatment is separate from capital gains, so a sale can be GST/HST-exempt yet still produce a taxable capital gain. Second, gold inside a TFSA or RRSP follows those accounts' rules, and not all physical gold qualifies. Keep every invoice, shipping receipt and sale record: without proof of your ACB, the Canada Revenue Agency may not accept your claimed cost, and you could be taxed on the full sale price. Gains are reported on Schedule 3 of your tax return. See also goldcalculator.ca's guide to tax on gold in Canada.

Where to sell: comparing your options

BuyerTypical payoutTrade-offs
Specialist bullion dealerHighest for bars and coinsTransparent pricing, published buyback
Local jewellerFair for jewellery, sometimes above meltMay pay for craftsmanship
Online dealer (insured mail-in)Often competitive for bullionShipping risk and wait; check insurance and free return
Pawn shopUsually lowestInstant cash, steep margins
Private saleCan be high, but uncertainNo dealer margin, but no assay or security

For most sellers, a specialist dealer is the right default; a jeweller is the second quote for fine jewellery.

Comparing dealer quotes fairly, step by step

  1. Get three quotes on the same day. Spot moves, so quotes from different days are not comparable. Tell each dealer exactly what you have: weight, karat, sealed or not.
  2. Ask for the per-gram price. A lump-sum offer hides the margin. Divide the offer by the pure-gold weight and compare that per-gram figure across dealers.
  3. Ask for the formula. A good dealer answers in one sentence, such as spot minus 2%. A vague answer usually means a large margin.
  4. Confirm what is deducted. Ask whether stones, clasps and non-gold parts are excluded, and whether any testing, refining or handling fee applies on top.
  5. Check payment terms. Same-day bank transfer or Interac e-Transfer is standard at reputable dealers. Be cautious of cheques with a long hold, or payment only in store credit.

Red flags: walk away when you see these

  • An offer far below the other quotes. One low quote is usually a margin problem, not a market view.
  • Pressure to decide immediately. A dealer who says the price expires in minutes is selling urgency, not gold.
  • No identification, no paperwork, cash only. A legitimate dealer documents every purchase.
  • Melting before agreeing a price. Never let a buyer melt your gold before the price basis is agreed in writing.
  • Promises of retail value for scrap. A buyer promising retail value for broken chains usually recovers it in a hidden deduction.
  • Unsolicited buyers. Door-to-door buyers and pop-up hotel buying events have the worst track record in Canada. Use an established dealer with a fixed address.

Done in this order, selling gold in Canada is a calm, documented transaction. See also our guides to gold dealers in Canada before choosing a buyer, and our guide to gold premiums to understand the other side of the spread.

FAQ

How much do dealers pay for gold in Canada?

Dealers pay melt value minus a margin: roughly 1–3% below spot for sealed bullion, 2–5% for unsealed bars and coins, 5–20% below melt value for jewellery and scrap.

Do I pay tax when I sell gold in Canada?

A profit on gold is generally a capital gain, with 50% included in taxable income and reported on Schedule 3. GST/HST-exempt bullion can still produce a taxable gain. General information only — speak to a tax professional.

What ID do I need to sell gold in Canada?

Reputable dealers ask for government-issued photo ID and keep a transaction record. Bring ID, your invoice if you have it, and any assay certificate.

Should I sell gold to a pawn shop or a dealer?

For value, a specialist dealer almost always beats a pawn shop. Get a dealer quote first, even if you need cash today.

Can I sell gold online safely in Canada?

Yes, with an established dealer offering fully insured shipping, free return if you decline, and payment by bank transfer or e-Transfer. Never mail gold uninsured.

About the Gold Prices Today Canada Team

The Gold Prices Today Canada Team follows the Canadian gold market every trading day, converting live international spot prices into Canadian dollars per gram, per ounce and per tola for buyers and sellers across the country. We cross-check our figures against published dealer and refiner prices, and every calculator on this site is tested against worked examples before it goes live — so the number you plan with is a number you can defend at the counter.

How we calculate our rates·More about the team